Quick answer: Most anal fissures heal without surgery. Treatment starts with softer stools (fiber, fluids, and a stool softener) and warm sitz baths. If a fissure hasn’t healed after a few weeks, a prescription ointment that relaxes the anal sphincter — diltiazem, nifedipine, or nitroglycerin — restores blood flow so the tear can close. Chronic fissures that don’t respond may need Botox injections or a minor surgery called lateral internal sphincterotomy (LIS).
A bowel movement feels like passing glass, then the pain lingers. You may see a streak of bright red blood on the toilet paper, start dreading the bathroom, and wonder why something so small hurts so much.
An anal fissure is often small in size but outsized in misery. The good news is that surgery is often not needed as a first step. The best treatment for anal fissure depends on how long it has been there, how severe the pain is, whether constipation is part of the problem, and whether you’re dealing with a first episode or a stubborn recurrence.
For many adults, the right path is a combination: softer stools, less straining, local care, and a prescription topical that relaxes the internal anal sphincter so blood flow can return and the tear can heal. When that fails, we consider Botox or surgery. The key is choosing the right step at the right time.
What Is an Anal Fissure, and Why Won’t It Heal?
A common pattern goes like this: one hard bowel movement causes a sharp tear, the next one hurts even more, and within days the bathroom becomes something to dread. That is often how an anal fissure starts.
An anal fissure is a small tear in the lining of the anal canal. The classic description is sharp pain during a bowel movement, often followed by burning, aching, or throbbing that can last for minutes to hours. A small streak of bright red blood on the toilet paper is also common (Cleveland Clinic).
Acute versus chronic fissures
Duration matters because it changes what usually works. Clinicians generally call a fissure acute if it has lasted less than six weeks and chronic if it lasts longer (StatPearls).
-
Acute fissure: present for less than 6 weeks
-
Chronic fissure: lasts longer, keeps reopening, or develops signs of poor healing such as a raised edge or a small skin tag nearby
New fissures often heal with the right early treatment. Chronic fissures are less forgiving. By that point, patients are often dealing with repeated spasm, fear of bowel movements, and tissue that has been reinjured over and over.
Why healing stalls
The problem is not just the tear itself. The anal sphincter often goes into spasm after the injury. That increases pain and reduces blood flow to the area, which slows healing. Then another hard stool, loose urgent stool, or a straining episode splits the tissue again.
That cycle explains why a fissure can linger even in otherwise healthy people.
It also explains a point many generic guides miss. The best treatment for anal fissure is not just the strongest cream. The treatment has to match the reason the fissure is still present. If spasm is driving pain, prescription topicals such as nitroglycerin or diltiazem may help. When constipation is the main trigger, stool management usually matters more than adding another ointment. And some patients with an overactive pelvic floor also benefit from pelvic floor therapy.
Why it keeps coming back
In practice, fissures recur for a few predictable reasons. Stool is too hard. Bowel movements are delayed because patients are trying to avoid pain. Diarrhea or frequent wiping keeps irritating the area. The sphincter stays tight enough that the tear never gets a quiet stretch of time to close.
Certain groups need a more individualized plan. Pregnancy and the postpartum period change bowel habits and limit which medications make sense. Patients taking GLP-1 medications may develop constipation severe enough to keep reopening a fissure unless that side of the problem is treated directly. Diet can help, and a practical starting point is this guide to high-fiber foods for constipation.
A fissure is a small wound in a difficult location. It heals well when stool is easy to pass, spasm settles down, and the tissue gets adequate blood flow. If one of those pieces is missing, the fissure often stays active.
First-Line Anal Fissure Treatment: Stool Softeners, Fiber, and Sitz Baths
Every anal fissure treatment plan starts with the same goal: make bowel movements soft and easy to pass so the tear stops reopening. Guidelines from the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons recommend this conservative care as the first step for most fissures (AAFP summary of the ASCRS guideline).
- Fiber and fluids. Add fiber gradually through food or a psyllium supplement, and drink enough water for it to work. Fiber without fluid can make stool harder.
- A stool softener or gentle laxative. Docusate or polyethylene glycol (MiraLAX) can take the strain out of bowel movements while the tear heals. See our guide to choosing a stool softener for anal fissure.
- Warm sitz baths. Soaking for 10 to 15 minutes after bowel movements helps relax the anal sphincter and eases pain. Here’s how to take a sitz bath.
- Topical numbing for pain. Lidocaine can take the edge off bowel movements, but it doesn’t help the tear heal. Learn when lidocaine cream for fissure pain makes sense.
When to move beyond first-line care
Many new (acute) fissures heal with these steps alone. If yours isn’t clearly improving after a few weeks, or it’s one that keeps coming back, the next step is a prescription ointment that relaxes the sphincter, covered below.
For a day-by-day home care plan, including the GLP-1 and pelvic floor factors that keep fissures from healing, see our guide on how to heal an anal fissure. If you’re wondering which DIY remedies help and which do more harm than good, see home remedies for anal fissure.
Prescription Anal Fissure Medication: Diltiazem vs. Nifedipine vs. Nitroglycerin
You have softened the stool, stopped straining, and are still getting that sharp tearing pain after a bowel movement. That is usually the point where prescription treatment becomes useful. The goal is straightforward. Relax the internal anal sphincter enough to improve blood flow so the fissure has a fair chance to heal (Mayo Clinic).
Comparing prescription fissure ointments
For most patients, the primary choice is not whether a topical can help. It is which one you are likely to tolerate long enough to get results.
| Treatment | How it helps | What to expect | Main downsides | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nitroglycerin ointment | Relaxes the internal sphincter and improves local blood flow | Can reduce spasm-related pain and support healing in selected patients | Headaches are common and can be strong enough to stop treatment | Patients with marked spasm who can tolerate nitrate side effects and are not taking interacting medications |
| Diltiazem 2% ointment | Relaxes the anal sphincter with less systemic effect | Often chosen first because patients tend to stay on it more consistently | Local irritation or itching can happen | Many adults with chronic fissure symptoms, especially those prone to headaches |
| Nifedipine ointment | Calcium channel blocker that relaxes the internal sphincter and improves blood flow | Works similarly to diltiazem; usually applied for several weeks | Possible local irritation; occasional headache or flushing | Adults who want a gentler alternative to nitroglycerin, or who didn’t tolerate diltiazem |
| Botulinum toxin | Temporarily relaxes the sphincter through injection | Considered after topical failure or when surgery is being deferred | Office procedure, variable durability, may need repeat treatment | Patients who want a middle step before surgery |
| Lateral internal sphincterotomy | Surgically lowers resting sphincter pressure | Highest and most reliable healing rates for chronic fissures | Small but real risk of continence changes | Chronic fissures that have not healed with medical treatment |
For a side-by-side breakdown of all three, see diltiazem vs. nitroglycerin vs. nifedipine.
Side effects and success rates
Diltiazem is generally better tolerated with fewer side effects, while nitroglycerin offers strong sphincter relaxation but comes with a higher rate of headaches. Topical nitroglycerin heals about half of chronic fissures, and at least 30% of people who use it get headaches (AAFP summary of ASCRS guidelines). The right choice depends on your medical history, side-effect tolerance, and what you’re taking currently. For a full comparison of ingredients, pricing, and how to get a prescription cream shipped to you, see our complete guide to anal fissure cream.
Bummed’s prescription creams are compounded with these same muscle-relaxing ingredients. Long-Acting uses diltiazem and is our go-to for fissures; Sensitive Care uses nifedipine for sensitive skin. A 3-month supply is $65, plus a $49 first visit with a licensed provider.
Botox and Surgery for Chronic Anal Fissures
You have used the cream, softened the stool, adjusted the bowel routine, and the pain still snaps back with each bowel movement. That is usually the point where we stop asking whether the fissure hurts and start asking whether it has become a chronic wound that needs a different level of treatment.
Botulinum toxin as a middle step
Botulinum toxin injection relaxes the internal anal sphincter for a limited time. The goal is simple. Lower the spasm, improve blood flow, and give the tear a better chance to close without cutting the muscle.
This option appeals to patients who want to preserve the sphincter and avoid surgery if possible. That matters in people with higher concern about control issues, including some postpartum patients, older adults, and anyone who already has borderline leakage or pelvic floor weakness.
The trade-off is reliability. Botox can work well, but healing is less predictable than with surgery, and some fissures return after the effect wears off. In practice, it fits best as a middle step for a chronic fissure that has not healed with proper topical treatment, especially when surgery feels like too big a jump.
Some clinicians also use compounded anorectal treatments alongside procedural care in selected cases. If you want background on one ingredient that sometimes comes up in fissure-related care, this overview of metronidazole in anal healing treatment explains where it may fit.
Lateral internal sphincterotomy
Lateral internal sphincterotomy, or LIS, is the operation with the most consistent track record for chronic anal fissure. It’s more effective than medication, with healing rates of at least 88% that hold for up to six years (AAFP summary of ASCRS guidelines). It works by partially dividing the internal sphincter to reduce the high resting pressure that keeps the fissure from healing.
For the right patient, it is the fastest route to durable relief. Pain often improves quickly. Healing is usually more dependable than with Botox or repeated rounds of medication.
The primary decision point is continence risk. Even a small chance of lasting trouble with gas or stool control matters, and we discuss that directly before recommending LIS. A patient with prior anorectal surgery, baseline leakage, multiple vaginal deliveries, or weak sphincter function needs a more cautious discussion than a young, otherwise healthy patient with a classic chronic posterior fissure.
LIS is often the most effective treatment for a chronic fissure that has failed medical therapy, but it has to match the patient’s anatomy, symptoms, and tolerance for risk.
How we decide to escalate care
We consider a procedure when the fissure has moved out of the short-term, medication-responsive phase and into a pattern that keeps disrupting daily life. Common signs include persistent severe pain, repeat tearing despite good stool control, or exam findings that suggest a chronic fissure such as exposed muscle fibers or a sentinel tag (American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons).
At that stage, the question is not which option sounds less intimidating. The question is which option gives the best balance of healing, comfort, and bowel control for that specific patient.
A patient who wants to avoid cutting the sphincter may reasonably try Botox first. A patient with months of severe pain, clear chronic changes, and failed topical therapy may get better faster with LIS.
Which Anal Fissure Treatment Is Right for You?
The right plan changes depending on the person sitting in front of us. Here are the situations that come up most often.
Pregnancy and postpartum
This group needs extra care around constipation, hydration, and topical selection. The first priorities are gentle stool consistency, reducing strain, and avoiding products that create more irritation than benefit.
In practice, we lean heavily on fiber, fluids, stool-softening strategies, and prescription topicals that a provider reviews for appropriateness in pregnancy or postpartum recovery. The practical goal isn’t aggressive experimentation. It’s a steady plan you can continue.
If pain and tissue irritation are both prominent, some providers may also consider combination approaches used in anal healing care, depending on the overall presentation.
GLP-1 medication users
Adults taking GLP-1 medications often run into constipation as the hidden driver of fissure pain. If that’s your situation, the fissure won’t improve reliably unless bowel habits improve at the same time.
This group often does best with earlier, more intentional bowel management:
-
Daily hydration habits: not just catching up at night.
-
Consistent fiber intake: food first, then supplements if needed.
-
Prompt response to constipation: don’t wait several days hoping it will resolve on its own.
-
Prescription topical support: when pain and spasm have already started.
For many GLP-1 users, the fissure is not the first problem. The stool pattern is.
First-time acute fissures versus recurring chronic fissures
A first-time acute fissure usually deserves a conservative first pass, especially if the trigger was obvious, such as hard stool, travel constipation, or a short period of straining. Many acute fissures respond to stool regulation, warm baths, and a prescription topical, like those from Bummed.
A recurring or chronic fissure is different. At that point, we stop pretending it’s just a temporary skin irritation. Recurrent pain, repeated bleeding, and ongoing spasm usually mean you need a more structured treatment plan and possibly a procedural discussion.
The main mistake is undertreating a chronic fissure with occasional over-the-counter products while hoping it behaves like a fresh one.
How Long Does Anal Fissure Treatment Take?
A common pattern is feeling better after a few days, then stopping treatment too soon. Pain often settles before the fissure has healed, especially if bowel movements are still hard or the internal sphincter is still in spasm.
For an early fissure, improvement often starts before full closure. For a chronic fissure, healing usually takes longer and requires a steadier plan. As noted earlier, topical treatment is usually given a real trial before anyone talks seriously about a procedure. In practice, that means sticking with the bowel regimen, using the medication as prescribed, and judging progress over weeks rather than day to day.
We tell patients to watch for trends, not one good afternoon.
Signs your fissure is healing
Good signs include less pain after bowel movements, less bleeding, and less fear around going to the bathroom. If pain stays intense, bleeding keeps recurring, or symptoms improve and then quickly return, the treatment plan may need to change. That can mean adjusting the topical, tightening up constipation management, or arranging an in-person exam to confirm the diagnosis.
How telehealth can help
Telehealth works well for the first part of this process because the early decisions are usually practical. A provider can help you decide which topical makes sense for you, whether nitroglycerin headaches are likely to be a deal-breaker, and whether diltiazem is the better first prescription. They’ll also consider whether pregnancy, breastfeeding, GLP-1 related constipation, or recurrent fissures should change the plan from the start.
A telehealth visit can help with:
-
Getting treatment started sooner
-
Reviewing your symptom pattern and likely fissure type
-
Choosing between prescription topicals based on side effects and context
-
Building a bowel plan that matches your actual trigger
-
Setting a clear point for follow-up or escalation
For a broader look at why virtual care fits urgent but nonemergency problems, see how telehealth is changing acute care access.
Telehealth has limits. Heavy bleeding, fever, drainage, a new lump, marked swelling, or concern for an abscess or another diagnosis should be assessed in person. The same is true if symptoms are not tracking in the right direction after a fair trial of treatment.
Anal Fissure Treatment FAQs
What is the fastest way to heal an anal fissure?
Keep stools soft and easy to pass (fiber, fluids, and a stool softener), take warm sitz baths after bowel movements, and avoid straining. If the fissure isn’t improving within a few weeks, a prescription ointment that relaxes the anal sphincter usually speeds healing more than anything you can buy over the counter. Our step-by-step guide covers how to heal an anal fissure fast.
What is the best medicine for anal fissures?
For fissures that don’t heal with stool softening alone, prescription ointments that relax the anal sphincter are the standard next step. Diltiazem and nifedipine are often preferred because they cause fewer headaches than nitroglycerin. Numbing creams like lidocaine ease pain but don’t help the tear heal. The best choice depends on your history and how well you tolerate side effects, which a provider can help you weigh.
Is there an over-the-counter treatment for anal fissures?
Over-the-counter options like stool softeners, fiber, sitz baths, and lidocaine can ease pain and help acute fissures heal. There’s no over-the-counter version of the muscle-relaxing ointments (diltiazem, nifedipine, nitroglycerin) that treat the spasm behind chronic fissures. Those need a prescription. See our guide to anal fissure creams and ointments.
How long does anal fissure treatment take?
Pain often improves within days of starting treatment, but healing takes longer. Prescription ointments are typically used for several weeks, and providers judge progress over weeks rather than day to day. Stopping as soon as the pain eases is a common reason fissures come back.
What happens if an anal fissure is left untreated?
Many new fissures heal on their own, but some become chronic and reopen with each hard bowel movement. Over time, a chronic fissure can develop a small skin tag (sentinel pile) and become harder to heal without prescription treatment or a procedure. Pain also makes people put off bowel movements, which hardens stool and keeps the cycle going.
How do you get rid of an anal fissure?
Break the cycle that keeps it open: soften stool, stop straining, and relax the sphincter spasm that cuts off blood flow. Most people get there with first-line care plus a prescription ointment. Fissures that still haven’t healed after a full course of treatment may need Botox or a minor surgery called lateral internal sphincterotomy (LIS).
Can an anal fissure heal on its own?
Some can, especially early fissures tied to one episode of hard stool. But many don’t heal smoothly because pain triggers spasm and poor blood flow. If symptoms are persisting, recurring, or making you dread bowel movements, it’s time to treat the cause rather than wait it out.
When should I be worried about bleeding?
Small streaks of bright red blood can happen with fissures. Bleeding deserves prompt evaluation if it is heavy, recurrent without a clear cause, associated with dizziness, or paired with other concerning symptoms. Persistent anorectal bleeding shouldn’t be self-diagnosed.
Is it an anal fissure or a hemorrhoid?
Fissures usually cause sharp pain during bowel movements, while hemorrhoids are more likely to cause pressure, swelling, or itching, and the two can happen together. Here’s how to tell the difference between hemorrhoids and anal fissures.
References
- American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons clinical practice guidelines for anal fissures, summarized in American Family Physician, February 2024.
- American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons. Anal Fissure.
- StatPearls. Anal Fissures. NCBI Bookshelf.
- Cleveland Clinic. Anal Fissure: What It Is, Symptoms, Causes & Treatment.
- Mayo Clinic. Anal fissure: Diagnosis and treatment.
If you’re dealing with fissure pain now, Bummed offers a discreet telehealth pathway to review symptoms with a physician online and, if appropriate, receive a prescription treatment plan shipped from our partner pharmacy.
Bummed content is for general education and should never replace professional medical advice that considers your individual health. If you think you’re experiencing a medical emergency, call 911 or head to the nearest emergency department.
Prescription products require an online consultation with a physician who will determine if a prescription is appropriate.