Back to articles

Anal Fissure From Bottoming: How to Heal It and When You Can Bottom Again

Anal fissure from bottoming

Quick answer: An anal fissure is a small tear in the lining of the anal canal, and receptive anal sex is one of the most common causes. Most tears from bottoming are shallow and heal well with soft stools, sitz baths and, if needed, a prescription cream that relaxes the sphincter. Take 4 to 8 weeks off bottoming so it heals fully, then return slowly, starting small.

  • Sharp, paper-cut pain during sex or your next bowel movement is the classic sign.
  • Soft stools and sitz baths heal about half of new fissures; Rx creams like diltiazem help many of the rest.
  • A fissure that lasts longer than 6 weeks is chronic. Botox or surgery are options if creams don’t work.

You felt a sting during sex, and now every bowel movement feels like passing broken glass. That’s an anal fissure, and if you bottom, you’re far from alone. The good news: tears from bottoming are usually the easier kind to heal. The less fun news: healing means a real break, not a few days. Here’s the full plan, from Bummed’s Chief Medical Officer, colorectal surgeon Dr. Carmen Fong.

Why bottoming causes anal fissures

The anal canal is lined with thin, sensitive skin that doesn’t make its own lubrication. Penetration without enough lube, warm-up or relaxation can stretch it past its limit and split it. Douching too forcefully and toy use can do the same.

The link is well documented. In a 2024 survey of 1,100 people with prostates, anal fissures were the only colorectal diagnosis tied to receptive anal sex, and the rate rose with more lifetime exposure (Gaither et al., LGBT Health, 2024). In an Australian study of gay and bisexual men, a self-reported anal tear was the only symptom independently linked to recent receptive anal sex (Goddard et al., Sexual Health, 2021).

Constipation, hard stools and diarrhea still matter. They’re the most common causes of fissures overall, and they can reopen a tear that sex started.

Signs you have a fissure

  • Sharp, cutting or burning pain during sex or with bowel movements
  • Pain or spasm that lingers for minutes to hours afterward
  • A streak of bright red blood on toilet paper, a condom or a toy
  • A small lump or skin tag at the edge of the anus (common with chronic fissures)

“Pain with bowel movements is often the first symptom people notice, but for those engaging in receptive anal sex, discomfort during or after intercourse can be the earliest sign,” Dr. Fong told Out.

If your symptoms are more itch and swelling than sharp pain, it may be a hemorrhoid instead. See anal sex and hemorrhoids.

Superficial vs chronic fissures

Most fissures heal because they get a break from trauma and enough blood flow. Chronic fissures get stuck: pain makes the internal sphincter spasm, the spasm cuts blood flow, and the tear can’t close.

Tears from sex often avoid that trap. “Superficial tears, more common with external trauma like bottoming or douching or toy use without proper lubrication or warm ups, may not involve this spasm and often heal more quickly,” Dr. Fong told Out.

 

Acute (new) fissure Chronic fissure
How long Under 6 weeks Over 6 weeks, or keeps coming back
What’s going on Fresh, shallow tear Deeper tear held open by sphincter spasm
Usual first step Soft stools, sitz baths, time off Prescription cream that relaxes the sphincter
If that fails Rx cream Botox, then surgery

 

One more thing to know: most fissures sit at the back of the anal canal. Fissures off to the side, or more than one, can be a sign of an STI like syphilis, Crohn’s disease or another condition, and need an in-person exam (ASCRS guidelines, via AAFP).

How to heal an anal fissure from bottoming

Step 1: Stop the trauma and soften your stool

  • Pause bottoming, toys and douching.
  • Get 25 to 35 g of fiber a day and plenty of water so bowel movements pass without pushing. A stool softener can help.
  • Take a warm sitz bath for 10 to 20 minutes, a few times a day and after bowel movements.
  • Clean with warm water and pat dry. Skip wipes.

This alone heals about half of acute fissures (ASCRS guidelines, via AAFP).

Step 2: Prescription cream if it isn’t healing

If pain isn’t clearly improving after a week or two, or the fissure keeps reopening, a prescription cream that relaxes the internal sphincter is the next step. Calcium channel blockers like diltiazem work about as well as nitroglycerin with fewer side effects, and ASCRS supports them as a first-line treatment for chronic fissures (ASCRS guidelines, via Guideline Central).

 

Bummed cream Key active ingredient Best for
Long-Acting Diltiazem Most fissures; first choice for healing
Rapid Relief Nitroglycerin Faster pain relief for some; can cause headaches; not used in pregnancy or breastfeeding
Sensitive Care Nifedipine Sensitive skin or people who don’t tolerate nitroglycerin

Bummed’s compounded creams can also include a local anesthetic to make bowel movements less painful while you heal. Not sure which fits? Diltiazem vs nitroglycerin vs nifedipine compares them side by side.

Start healing this week. A Bummed provider can review your symptoms online and, if appropriate, prescribe Long-Acting or another compounded cream, shipped discreetly. Treatments are $65 for a 3-month supply, plus a $49 first visit. Find my treatment

Step 3: Botox or surgery for chronic fissures

If creams don’t work, Botox injected into the internal sphincter relaxes it for a few months so the fissure can close. Botox heals roughly 60% to 85% of chronic fissures, though 30% to 40% can come back within 1 to 3 years (systematic review, 2025). Dr. Fong told Out that Botox works well enough that she rarely needs to operate.

Lateral internal sphincterotomy (LIS), a small surgery that partly divides the sphincter, heals 90% to 95% of chronic fissures but carries a 5% to 15% risk of some loss of bowel control (same review). If you bottom, tell your surgeon. It’s a fair question to factor into which option you choose.

For more on each option, see how to heal an anal fissure and the best treatment for anal fissure.

How long to wait before bottoming again

Dr. Fong’s advice is a full break. “I recommend taking 4 to 8 weeks off bottoming,” she told Out. “Sorry guys, but it helps your bottoming longevity to have these heal all the way instead of just partially, resulting in new fissures down the line.”

A partly healed fissure tears easily, and repeat tears are how acute fissures turn chronic. Use these checkpoints rather than the calendar alone:

☐ Bowel movements are pain-free

☐ No blood on toilet paper for at least a week

☐ You’ve finished your prescribed cream, or your provider has cleared you

☐ At least 4 weeks have passed since the tear

How to get back to bottoming safely

Dr. Fong’s rule for coming back: “start small and go slow.”

  1. Start solo. Use a well-lubricated finger or a small dilator. “The smallest dilators are pencil thin, but I’d say start with something index finger size,” Dr. Fong told Them.
  2. Pay attention to the feeling. Stretch and pressure are fine. Sharp, cutting pain or more than a trace of blood means stop and give it more time.
  3. Size up gradually, over several sessions, before bringing in a partner.
  4. With a partner, go slow and stay in control. Extended foreplay, lots of lube, and positions where you set the depth and pace.
  5. Keep your bowels on track. Soft, regular stool protects the scar while it strengthens. See what to eat before bottoming.

Can gradual stretching help? For some chronic fissures driven by a tight sphincter, careful dilation can improve blood flow, much like Botox does. Dr. Fong told Them that anal dilation “can technically be a treatment for chronic anal fissures,” but it isn’t a first-line option, and she wouldn’t try it with an acute fissure, which “would hurt and not heal.” Talk to a provider before trying it.

How to prevent another fissure

  • Use more lube than you think you need, and reapply often.
  • Warm up with fingers or a small toy before anything bigger.
  • Avoid numbing lube; it hides warning pain.
  • Douche gently with a small amount of warm water, or skip it.
  • Keep stool soft and regular all the time, not just before sex.
  • Stop at sharp pain, every time.

Frequently asked questions

How long does an anal fissure from sex take to heal?

A shallow tear can feel better within days, but full healing usually takes several weeks. That’s why Dr. Fong recommends 4 to 8 weeks off bottoming. A fissure that lasts more than 6 weeks is considered chronic and usually needs prescription treatment.

Can I bottom with an anal fissure?

No. Bottoming with an open fissure reopens it, slows healing and raises the chance it becomes chronic. Wait until you’ve met the checkpoints above.

Will a fissure heal on its own?

Many acute fissures do, as long as you stop the trauma and keep stools soft. If it isn’t clearly improving after a week or two, a prescription cream can help it close.

Is a fissure from bottoming different from one caused by constipation?

The tear is the same, but tears from sex are often shallower and may heal faster because they don’t always trigger sphincter spasm. Constipation can still reopen either kind.

Do I need to see someone in person?

See a provider in person if you have heavy bleeding, fever, swelling or drainage, a fissure that isn’t in the usual spot, more than one fissure, or a fissure that hasn’t healed with treatment.

Bummed content is for general education and should never replace professional medical advice that considers your individual health. If you think you’re experiencing a medical emergency, call 911 or head to the nearest emergency department.

Prescription products require an online consultation with a physician who will determine if a prescription is appropriate. Consult with a medical provider before starting any medications, especially if you’re pregnant or breastfeeding.

References

  1. Gaither TW, et al. Receptive anal intercourse: impact on colorectal and urologic diagnoses. LGBT Health. 2024. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1089/lgbt.2023.0469
  2. Goddard SL, et al. Self-reported anal symptoms and their association with anal pathology among gay and bisexual men. Sexual Health. 2021. https://publish.csiro.au/sh/Fulltext/sh20104
  3. Davids JS, et al. ASCRS clinical practice guidelines for the management of anal fissures. Dis Colon Rectum. 2023. Summaries: https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2024/0200/practice-guidelines-anal-fissures.html and https://guidelinecentral.com/guideline/2419059
  4. Efficacy of botulinum toxin in the treatment of chronic anal fissure: a comprehensive systematic review. 2025. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12333800/
  5. Messman-Rucker A. Anal fissures are painful and common. Here’s how to heal and get back to bottoming. Out. 2026. https://www.out.com/health/anal-fissures-treatment
  6. Messman-Rucker A. How to heal anal fissures and hemorrhoids? Try bottoming, experts say. Them. 2026.